Screw You, "New Year, New You"
The January onslaught of "new you" messaging is giving mental health disorders to women at an alarming rate. Plus, whether resolutions can ever be mentally healthy.
How “New Year, New You” Is Causing Eating Disorders
When you see the words “New Year, New You,” you might roll your eyes and prepare for a diet ad.
Or you might check into an eating disorder clinic.
According to a first-of-its-kind study published in Psychosomatic Medicine, nearly 20 percent of people admitted into an eating disorder (ED) treatment facility said that anti-obesity, pro-dieting messaging drove them there.
Messaging like “New Year, New You.” Once a seemingly innocuous resolutions rallying cry, the phrase has come to mean something more sinister: There’s something wrong with your body.
The messaging has gone far beyond gyms and weight loss programs. It’s made its way to medical centers, universities, even the NIH. This omnipresence isn’t just an issue for the 9 percent of Americans—or nearly 29 million people—who will have an eating disorder in their lifetime. (Though, that should be quite enough, shouldn’t it?)
Research and experts agree: The idea of “New Year, New You” can trigger anyone with a history of disordered eating, body concerns, weight struggles, or self-confidence issues. We don’t have the math skills to add up how many human beings that would encompass.
And this kind of triggering can be deadly. Someone dies every 52 minutes as a direct consequence of an ED, according to the National Eating Disorders Association (NEDA).
Our special package shines a light on the insidious way a four-word phrase is making women sick, what January feels like for people who have had EDs, how to prepare yourself for the diet-messaging avalanche, and what we all can do to do better moving forward.
Friends, Enemies, or Frenemies?
Are New Year’s Resolutions Ever Good for Mental Health?
This is what Eileen Anderson, Ed.D., founding director of the Medicine, Society, and Culture Center at Case Western Reserve University School of Medicine, told Mental about New Year’s resolutions.
While there’s nothing wrong with wanting to do things that make you feel good or improve your health, it’s easy to go off the rails when so much of the marketing around New Year’s resolutions promises unattainable and unsustainable results—or wraps unhealthy products and services in shiny, happy health messaging.
Many mental health pros now recommend setting intentions over resolutions (if you want to set them at all). What’s the difference? Intentions align with your values and allow you to celebrate little successes each day.
Learn the fine line between helpful and harmful, and get six pro tips on how to set (mentally and physically) healthy intentions.
Fun Little Game
What’s Your New Year’s Name?
Look, we don’t believe in manifesting unless you take actions to back up the desire. But putting your hopes out into the universe is step 1. So… Mayor Cherry Bodies checking in, ma’am! We’d love to hear your name—write us at editors@clubmental.com or tell us in the comments. Here’s hoping for a 2024 filled with belonging, empowerment, and self-compassion. 💛